Accidents Defense St Petersburg

How Do I Prove Another Driver Hit My Car? –

Dolman Law Group

Think about you’ve been in an accident with one other driver. It appears clear to you the opposite driver is at fault as a result of, as you inform your folks, “he hit me, I didn’t hit him.”

In fact, Florida is a no-fault insurance coverage state so who-hit-who sometimes doesn’t come into play when accidents are slight and also you each drivers make a declare towards their very own obligatory private damage safety (PIP) and Private Injury Legal responsibility (PDL) protection. However, the story modifications when an accident causes extreme damage and also you select to take authorized motion towards the opposite driver for the medical bills, ache and struggling, and different damages not coated by no-fault insurance coverage.

To succeed on that sort of a declare, your lawyer should show the opposite driver’s fault to the satisfaction of the opposite driver’s insurance coverage firm or, if vital, to a decide and jury. Insurance coverage corporations, in fact, keep in enterprise by in search of to restrict their legal responsibility for paying advantages as a lot as potential. Offering detailed proof of fault to the service is how legal professionals push again towards a weak settlement supply from an insurance coverage adjuster making an attempt to maintain prices low. This similar detailed proof is useful if the insurance coverage firm refuses to be satisfied, and your lawyer should show your claims in courtroom.

This information will talk about proving the opposite driver’s fault in Florida automotive accident damage instances and supply some recommendations on methods of gathering proof to point out the opposite driver ought to bear authorized legal responsibility for the damages you sustained within the accident.

Proving Fault in Florida Automotive Accident Damage Instances

If you sue the opposite driver for accidents sustained in a automotive accident, you have to usually show the opposite driver was “at fault.” A method to do that is to point out the opposite driver meant for the accident to occur and tried to hurt you. For those who can show this, then the opposite driver shall be liable to you and, almost certainly, additionally headed to jail.

More often than not, nevertheless, the opposite driver wasn’t making an attempt to get right into a wreck any greater than you have been. As an alternative, your lawyer’s job can be to point out that the opposite driver is at fault as a result of he was negligent. Florida courts, like these in different states, consider 4 standards to determine whether or not somebody acts negligently. These standards apply to most varieties of private damage instances, however right here is the best way they match with a automotive accident damage or wrongful demise case:

Obligation of Care

The defendant should have an obligation of care in the direction of the plaintiff. In St. Petersburg, throughout Florida, and throughout the nation, drivers owe different motorists, pedestrians, bicyclists, and so on. an inexpensive obligation of care. That is the concept a driver gained’t drive a car in a approach which may fairly be anticipated to injure others. In different phrases, each driver owes each different driver an obligation of care to drive safely, and that features the opposite driver in your accident.

Breach of Obligation

The defendant should have breached his or her obligation of care in the direction of the plaintiff. This implies the opposite motorist drove in a fashion that would fairly be anticipated to trigger you hurt. A violation of visitors legal guidelines typically serves as proof of negligence in a automotive accident case, comparable to when drivers run pink lights, velocity, or drive underneath the affect of medicine or alcohol.


The defendant’s breach of the obligation of care should have been the “proximate cause” of the automotive accident that led to a plaintiff’s accidents. Legal professionals have crammed numerous regulation books writing about what this phrase means, however the primary concept that’s that the hurt the accident, and to a point, the plaintiff’s accidents in it, should have been a fairly foreseeable end result of the defendant’s breach of the obligation of care.


The accident should have resulted in demonstrable damages. In different phrases, should you have been a superhero driving an indestructible automotive, you wouldn’t have a declare towards the opposite driver even when he breached an obligation of care to you and brought on an accident, since neither you nor your automotive ended up broken within the accident. In fact, that’s by no means the case, and automotive accident victims are entitled to recuperate compensation for accidents that embrace present and future medical bills, misplaced wages, misplaced incomes capability, ache and struggling, and extra.

Ideas for Proving Another Driver Hit Your Automotive

If there’s a dispute over whether or not the opposite driver “hit you,” listed here are some tricks to be sure to get the knowledge it is advisable to maximize the probability of proving the opposite driver’s fault:

Get a Copy of the Police Report

When automotive accidents are critical, police and first responders sometimes present as much as the scene. Whether or not it’s Florida State Patrol or St. Petersburg Police, no less than one regulation enforcement company on the accident scene will file an official report of the accident. Police reviews are the written observations of the officer who got here to the accident, carried out a preliminary investigation, spoke to witnesses, and so forth. Police reviews typically include clues about legal responsibility, such because the presence of skid marks and if the opposite driver was cited for any visitors violations.

If it’s a busy day, or ambulance transport wasn’t wanted for the accident, there’s a probability that police gained’t present up on the scene of an accident. If that occurs, you must name them or go to the closest police station in St. Petersburg to file a report. The officer will take down your account of the accident and monitor down any witnesses to verify what occurred. Ensure to acquire a replica of the ultimate report; if the opposite driver was at fault, the police report will probably be top-of-the-line methods to show legal responsibility.

Collect Proof of Injury to Your Automotive

We’ve already mentioned the significance of calling the police and getting a police report instantly after a automotive accident, however in case you are bodily in a position, you might also profit from gathering proof of auto injury to your automotive as proof that the opposite driver hit your automotive. Take the time to get the names of witnesses who noticed the accident happen and their contact info. Additionally, use your cellphone to take movies or footage of auto injury to each automobiles. It is best to take footage of the complete scene, together with any particles that fell off of the automobiles.

When insurance coverage adjusters and investigators take a look at your car injury and footage, not solely are they capable of see that your injury got here from one other car, however they could additionally have the ability to show legal responsibility. For example:

  • Rear-finish collisions: If a automotive hits your car from behind, the rear-finish collision will virtually by no means be your fault, even should you have been stopped in the midst of the street. Driving safely requires leaving sufficient time and distance between the entrance of your automotive and the car in entrance of you, so you’ve gotten ample time to cease if the automotive in entrance of you makes a fast flip or sudden cease. When automobiles select to comply with too intently or not take note of the automotive in entrance of them, the regulation sides with the driving force in entrance and finds the driving force in again at fault. When a collision happens, the again of 1 automotive and the entrance of the opposite automotive are each broken leaving little to dispute about fault. But, there are some conditions the place you may share legal responsibility, reminiscent of your brake lights weren’t working.
  • Left-flip collisions: When motor automobiles make a left flip, they need to yield to oncoming visitors. If an accident happens, it’s virtually all the time the fault of the driving force making the flip. Some uncommon exceptions to this rule happen when the automotive touring straight was rushing or went via a pink mild. In left-flip accidents, the turning automotive’s passenger aspect is broken, in addition to the opposite automotive’s entrance finish. Left-flip accidents may additionally happen when a driver makes a left flip right into a automotive that’s touring in one other lane with out seeing them, inflicting injury to the drivers’ aspect of the oncoming car. The situation of the injury makes it troublesome to dispute the best way the accident occurred. Apart from the uncommon exception, the regulation will usually help the driving force of the non-turning car.

Use Visitors Legal guidelines to Help Your Case

Florida’s state visitors legal guidelines gained’t instantly show that one other driver hit your automotive, however they’ll assist show legal responsibility or fault in your automotive accident declare. When a driver has violated visitors laws, assigning fault and proving negligence in a Florida automotive accident case is a a lot easier process. If the police arrived on the scene of the accident, they could have already cited the opposite driver for visitors violations. In instances the place the police didn’t present up on the scene, you’ll have to perform a little analysis.

You possibly can analysis Florida’s visitors legal guidelines on-line, or head to your native library or Division of Motor Automobiles (DMV). Violating visitors violations comparable to failure to yield, rushing, and extra may need led to the accident or exacerbated accidents. Having a document of the regulation(s) that apply to your accident places you in an opportune place when coping with your insurance coverage firm or the opposite motorist’s service.

Comparative Negligence in Florida Automotive Accident Claims

Even when you, with the assistance of a professional lawyer, can current proof of fault to an insurance coverage firm or a Florida courtroom, it doesn’t essentially imply the opposite driver bears all the fault. Florida applies a pure comparative negligence rule to non-public damage instances, together with people who contain automotive accidents. Comparative negligence is the notion of shared legal responsibility, which means that you simply is perhaps partially at fault for the accident. In any authorized motion for damages, the rule requires a courtroom or jury to assign a proportion of fault to each social gathering, whether or not it’s 50 %/50 %, 100 %/zero %, or one thing in between. Any damages that the courtroom awards to the plaintiff are decreased by the share that the courtroom finds she or he contributed to the accident.

Contemplate the beforehand talked about left-flip accident state of affairs for illustration. A automotive makes a left flip in entrance of you as you touring down the street. You can’t keep away from the accident, so a visitors accident occurs. Generally, the courtroom would discover the opposite driver 100 % at fault on this state of affairs; nevertheless, you have been rushing. The plaintiff argues that had you not been rushing, the accident won’t have occurred or the influence would have been far much less. The courtroom finds that you’re 20 % at fault, or negligent, for the accident and your ensuing accidents.

In the event you and your lawyer determined to sue for $1,000,000 based mostly on losses incurred out of your damage and the courtroom gave a verdict in your favor, they scale back the award by 20 %. This implies you’re barred from recovering greater than $800,000 in damages. A talented automotive accident lawyer understands comparative negligence and can advocate to get the absolute best consequence in your state of affairs. Additional, they anticipate the arguments that the protection will make to shift legal responsibility and scale back the worth of your declare.

Contact a St. Petersburg Lawyer to Prove Fault in Your Automotive Accident Declare

Typically automotive accident claims are easy and easy, however typically occasions they’re complicated instances with a number of events and insurance coverage corporations. Florida’s no fault insurance coverage legal guidelines and PIP protection provides one other layer of complexity to automotive accident instances. We’ve got mentioned the issues that you are able to do to show fault in your automotive accident declare, however finally, the most effective determination is to rent an skilled private damage lawyer to steer you thru the authorized course of and allow you to know the appropriate time to escalate your insurance coverage declare to a private damage lawsuit.

When you have sustained accidents in a automotive accident in St. Petersburg or Pinellas County, contact our seasoned automotive accident attorneys at Dolman Regulation Group at (727) 222-6922 to schedule a free session to debate the small print of your case and study how we could possibly aid you get well the compensation you deserve.

Dolman Regulation Group
1663 1st Ave S.
St. Petersburg, FL 33712
(727) 222-6922

St. Petersburg Private Damage Lawyer